OpenvsClosed.aiGet updates

AI explained, in plain English

Should a few companies control AI, or should anyone be able to run it?

It is the biggest fight in technology right now. It will decide what AI costs, who gets to see what you type into it, and who decides what it will and won't do. This site explains it in plain English. No background needed.

Updated Nov 21, 2026 · About a 6-minute read · Glossary · Our 74 sources

The 60-second version

There are two kinds of AI

Closed AI

You rent it

It lives on the company's computers. You use it through an app or website, and whatever you type goes to them. The company sets the price and the rules.

Examples ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini

Open AI models

You can have a copy

The company publishes the AI itself. Anyone can download it for free, run it on their own computer, look inside it and change it.

Examples DeepSeek, Meta's Muse Spark Open, Google's Gemma

Don't let the name fool you. OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT, keeps its main AI closed. On this site, “open” always means AI that anyone can download.

PriceOpen AI costs far less. That decides how expensive the apps and services built on AI will be.
PrivacyWith open AI, what you type can stay on your own computer. With closed AI, it goes to the company.
PowerIf only a few companies have the best AI, they decide what everyone else can do with it.
4–10 mohow far behind the best open AI isQuestion 2
7×how much more closed AI costs for the same workQuestion 3
72%of the work on a major AI marketplace is done by open AIQuestion 3
3–3the score right now. It's a tieSee the score below

Question 1

What's the actual difference?

Think of a restaurant with a secret recipe. You can order the dish, but you never see how it is made, and the owner sets the price. That is closed AI. Now think of a recipe printed in a cookbook. Anyone can make it at home, change it, or open a restaurant of their own. That is open AI.

In practice, “open” means the company puts the AI itself on the internet as a file, and anyone can download a copy.

Figure 1.What it takes to run open AI. With closed AI, all three of these stay inside the company, and you only ever see the answers.

The upside of open

  • What you type stays on your own computer.
  • Nobody can raise your price or cut you off.
  • Anyone can test it for problems, including independent experts and governments.

The downside of open

  • Once it's released, it can never be taken back.
  • Whoever has a copy can remove its safety protections.
  • Even experts can't fully predict what an AI will do just by looking inside it.

Question 2

Is open AI as good as closed AI?

Almost. The best AI in the world today is closed. The best open AI is a few months behind it. “Four months behind” means today's best open AI is about as good as the best closed AI was four months ago.

Figure 2.How many months behind the best open AI is, according to five different tests. A dot is one estimate. A bar is a range. Source: Epoch AI, May 29, 2026 · NeoTeo, Sep 17, 2026 · Håvard Tveit Ihle, LessWrong, May 2026 · Second Source, Oct 17, 2026.

For everyday jobs like writing, summarizing and answering questions, most people would not notice the difference. For the very hardest problems, closed AI is still better.

What would change our mindIf open AI fell more than a year behind and stayed there.

Question 3

Is open AI cheaper?

Yes, by a lot. The file is free. You only pay for the computers to run it, and many companies compete to run it for you cheaply. The cheapest open AI costs about a tenth as much as a top closed one.

Figure 3.Advertised prices for the same amount of work. If a job costs $100 on a top closed AI, this is roughly what it costs on open ones. July 2026. Source: Tomasz Tunguz, Jul 20, 2026.

The people who build apps have noticed. When they are free to choose, they give most of the work to open AI, and mostly to the cheap ones. Add it all up and closed AI ends up costing about seven times as much for the same amount of work. That is why open AI does most of the work while most of the money still goes to closed AI.

Figure 4.Who does the work and who gets the money on OpenRouter, a marketplace where app makers choose between hundreds of AI models. September 2026. Source: OpenRouter, Sep 22, 2026.

Why should you care? Most apps you use don't run their own AI. They rent it. When that gets cheaper, the things built on it get cheaper, and more of them get built.

Question 4

Is open AI safe?

It has real risks, and so does the alternative. We back open AI, but the other side's worries are serious, so here they are next to our answers.

The worries

  • A released AI can't be recalled if something turns out to be wrong with it.
  • Criminals and hostile governments get the same tools as everyone else.
  • Some open models have weak protections. In a 2025 U.S. government test, one Chinese model went along with 94% of clearly harmful requests. American models went along with 8%.

Our answers

  • A ban only stops people who follow the law. Criminals don't.
  • The good guys need these tools too. In July, a company under attack by runaway AI could only defend itself with an open model, because the closed ones refused to help.
  • Weak protections are the maker's choice. In that same test, an American open model held up as well as the closed ones.
  • Test every powerful AI by the same rules, open or closed, and punish people who misuse it.

Read the full debate, including where the other side is right.

Question 5

Has anything like this happened before?

Three times. Each time, one company was in a position to control a technology everyone needed. Each time, a free version that anyone could copy broke that control, and ordinary people ended up with more choice and lower prices.

1995

Websites

The software that runs websites could have belonged to one company. A free, open version called Apache became the most popular within a year. That is a big reason anyone can afford to have a website.

1998

Web browsers

Microsoft's Internet Explorer had nine out of ten users and stopped improving. A free, open browser called Firefox changed that. Today Chrome, Safari and Firefox are all built on open software.

2008

Smartphones

Google gave its Android phone software away to any phone maker that wanted it. It now runs about seven in ten smartphones in the world, including most of the affordable ones.

In each case the open version was not the best at first. It was good enough, free to copy, and impossible to take away.

Question 6

What is the government doing about it?

Mostly, trying to control Chinese AI. Most of the best open models come from China, so the argument in Washington about open AI has become an argument about China.

There are two ways to make rules about a technology. You can punish people who use it to do harm. Or you can control the technology itself: who may publish it, who may use it, what labels it needs. Of the 12 things we are tracking, 6 would control the AI itself.

Law, rule or proposalWhat it would controlWhere it stands
Chinese AI disclosure ruleThe AI itselfUnder consideration · First reported Nov 18, 2026
Commission proposal to limit Chinese open modelsThe AI itselfRecommended to Congress, Nov 18, 2026 · No bill yet
House report on Chinese open modelsThe AI itselfPublished Nov 20, 2026 · Recommendations only
Bans and sanctions on Chinese open modelsThe AI itselfUnder discussion since Jul 2026 · Nothing imposed
AI off-switch billsThe AI itselfHouse bill introduced Jul 23, 2026 · Senate fast-track blocked Sep 16, 2026
China's AI export rulesThe AI itselfDraft published Oct 16, 2026 · Comments closed Nov 15 · Final list pending
State laws on the biggest AI modelsThe companies that make AICalifornia in effect since Jan 1, 2026 · New York and Illinois from Jan 1, 2027
Europe's AI lawThe companies that make AIIn force for general-purpose models since Aug 2, 2025
Chip rule for overseas data centersComputer chipsIssued Nov 16, 2026 · In effect since Nov 19
Open-Source AI Leadership Act (H.R. 10152)Nothing. It supports open AIReported to the full House, 26 to 21 · Awaiting a floor vote
White House AI safety policyNothing. It supports open AIAdopted Aug 2026 · Not released publicly
Proposal: legal protection for companies that release open modelsNothing. It supports open AIPolicy proposal · No bill yet
Figure 5.Everything we are tracking, sorted by what it would put under government control. As of Nov 21, 2026. Source: Reuters via The Globe and Mail, Nov 18, 2026 · U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, Nov 18, 2026 · Congress.gov.

Our view: punish misuse hard and test every powerful AI the same way. Rules that control the technology itself mostly end up protecting the biggest companies from competition. See every law in detail.

What would change our mindProof that a rule based on which country an AI came from actually prevented harm.

Question 7

Why does the best open AI come from China?

Because of where the money went. In the United States, investors and the best engineers went to companies that keep their AI closed, because selling access is an obvious way to make money. Giving your product away is not.

Chinese companies started behind. When you are behind, giving your product away is the fastest way to catch up and to undercut the leader. So they did. Chinese models now do about 69% of the work on that same marketplace.

America is starting to respond. Meta, Nvidia, Google and OpenAI have all released open models, and a House report in November called for a national program to build more. See who makes what. See which AI is open.

The score right now

● Updated Nov 21, 2026 · How we score

It's a tie. Closed AI is more capable, makes more money, and can be fixed after release. Open AI is cheaper, puts you in control, and does more of the actual work. The government hasn't picked a side.

What we compareOpen AIClosed AIWho's ahead
AbilityAbout 4 months behind on the broadest measure, and 8 to 10 months behind on tests the AI has never seen beforeHas the best AI availableClosed
PriceThe cheapest open model costs about 90% less than a top closed one. On average, closed AI costs about 7 times as much for the same amount of workPremium prices, set by the companyOpen
ControlYou can download it, look inside it, change it, and run it on your own computerYou rent it through one company's website or app, on that company's termsOpen
UsageDoes about 72% of the work on OpenRouter, a big marketplace where app makers choose between hundreds of AI modelsAbout 28%Open
MoneyGets about 27% of the money spent on that marketplace, up from 11% in JanuaryAbout 73%Closed
Fixing mistakesOnce it's released, copies can't be taken backThe company can fix it, limit it or switch it offClosed
WashingtonA bill backing American open AI is one vote from the full House. The White House's main AI policy leaves open models aloneFour moves in one week of November aimed at Chinese open models, which are most of the best open modelsNo point

Latest news

What happened this week

Each item is marked for the side it helped: open, closed, or both.

  1. Split

    House report: ban Chinese models in government, fund American open ones

    Two committees in the House of Representatives publish a report after a seven-month investigation. It asks the White House to stop federal agencies from using Chinese AI models. It also asks for a national program to build American open models, with government computers, shared safety testing and government purchasing behind it.

    via BankInfoSecurity, Reuters via The Jerusalem Post
  2. Point · Closed

    Cursor says it may drop Chinese open models

    Cursor, a popular AI tool for writing software, tells House investigators it will look at phasing out Chinese-made open models because of political risk. It has made no decision and set no date. Cursor built one of its own products on Kimi, a Chinese open model.

    via CNBC, Unite.AI, BankInfoSecurity
  3. Point · Open

    A new American open model: Inkling 2 Mini

    Thinking Machines, the AI company started by former OpenAI executive Mira Murati, releases a small model called Inkling 2 Mini that anyone can download. It joins a short list of American companies releasing open models.

    via AI Weekly
  4. Point · Closed

    White House weighs making companies disclose Chinese AI use

    Reuters reports the administration is considering a rule that would make U.S. companies publicly disclose their use of Chinese AI models. Three people familiar with the talks describe it as a way to discourage use without a ban that could anger industry or Beijing.

    via Reuters via The Globe and Mail
  5. Point · Closed

    Federal commission urges limits on Chinese open models in sensitive uses

    A federal commission that advises Congress on China sends in its yearly report. It recommends giving the Commerce Department 180 days to list sensitive uses, such as critical infrastructure, and to block new use of Chinese open models there unless their safety protections pass independent testing. It also recommends making governments and businesses disclose when they use them.

    via U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, CASRAI, FourWeekMBA
All 32 news items

Glossary

The words, in plain English

AI model
The “brain” behind an AI tool like ChatGPT. It is a huge file of numbers that a computer uses to turn your question into an answer.
Closed AI
AI you can only use through its maker's app or website. The model itself never leaves the company's computers.
Open AI model
AI whose maker has published the model for anyone to download and run. Not to be confused with OpenAI, the company, whose main models are closed.
Open-weights
The technical name for an open model. “Weights” are the numbers inside the file.
Open source
Software whose inner workings are published for anyone to read, use and change. People often say “open-source AI” when they mean open models.
Training
How an AI model is made: by feeding it enormous amounts of text and other data on thousands of powerful computers. It costs a fortune, which is why few companies can do it.
Safety protections
Rules built into an AI to make it refuse harmful requests. Insiders call them guardrails or safeguards.
Data center
A warehouse full of computers. Closed AI runs in its maker's data centers.
OpenRouter
A marketplace where people who build apps can choose between hundreds of AI models and switch easily. We use its numbers because they show what people pick when they have a free choice.
Hugging Face
The main website where open AI models are shared, a bit like an app store where everything is free.

Find out when the future shifts

One short email when a law changes or one of the four futures gets closer. Nothing else.

Want to weigh in? Build a letter to your representative.