{
  "site": {
    "name": "Open vs Closed",
    "domain": "openvsclosed.ai",
    "url": "https://openvsclosed.ai",
    "tagline": "Two kinds of AI. Four possible futures.",
    "description": "What happens if AI stays open to everyone, or ends up closed inside a few companies? Four possible futures, good and bad, in plain English, with the signs of each that are already here.",
    "updated": "2026-11-21",
    "signup_action": "",
    "signup_email_field": "email",
    "summary": "It's a tie. Closed AI is more capable, makes more money, and can be fixed after release. Open AI is cheaper, puts you in control, and does more of the actual work. The government hasn't picked a side."
  },
  "sources": {
    "bis_house": {
      "t": "House Lawmakers Push US AI Models to Counter China",
      "p": "BankInfoSecurity, Nov 20, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.bankinfosecurity.com/house-lawmakers-push-us-ai-models-to-counter-china-a-33482"
    },
    "cnbc_cursor": {
      "t": "Cursor tells lawmakers it's considering phasing out Chinese AI models",
      "p": "CNBC, Nov 20, 2026",
      "u": "https://cnbc.com/2026/11/20/cursor-chinese-ai-models-geopolitical-risk.html"
    },
    "unite_cursor": {
      "t": "Anysphere Weighs Moving Cursor Away From Chinese Open-Weight Models",
      "p": "Unite.AI, Nov 20, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.unite.ai/anysphere-weighs-moving-cursor-away-from-chinese-open-weight-models/"
    },
    "jpost_house": {
      "t": "Top House Republicans urge Trump to back cheaper US AI models",
      "p": "Reuters via The Jerusalem Post, Nov 20, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.jpost.com/american-politics/article-915606"
    },
    "aiweekly": {
      "t": "AI News Today, November 21",
      "p": "AI Weekly, Nov 21, 2026",
      "u": "https://aiweekly.co/ai-news-today"
    },
    "reuters_disclose": {
      "t": "Trump administration weighs forcing U.S. firms to disclose Chinese AI use",
      "p": "Reuters via The Globe and Mail, Nov 18, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/article-trump-administration-weighs-forcing-us-firms-to-disclose-chinese-ai/"
    },
    "uscc_ch8": {
      "t": "2026 Annual Report to Congress, Chapter 8",
      "p": "U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, Nov 18, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.uscc.gov/annual-report/2026/chapter-8-silicon-to-sovereignty-chinas-bid-to-control-the-ai-tech-stack"
    },
    "casrai_uscc": {
      "t": "USCC 2026 Report: Chips, AI, Data and Research",
      "p": "CASRAI, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://casrai.org/news/uscc-2026-annual-report-congress-china-technology-research-security"
    },
    "fwm_uscc": {
      "t": "USCC: 3 of 30 Fixes Target AI Stack",
      "p": "FourWeekMBA, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://fourweekmba.com/ai-uscc-pla-seeks-nvidia-chips-3-of-30-fixes-target-ai-stack/"
    },
    "nbc_bis": {
      "t": "U.S. closes loophole that let Chinese companies use top AI chips through foreign data centers",
      "p": "NBC News, Nov 16, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/us-closes-loophole-let-chinese-companies-use-top-ai-chips-rcna609634"
    },
    "orrick_bis": {
      "t": "U.S. Government Establishes Export Controls to Address China AI Remote Access Concerns",
      "p": "Orrick, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://www.orrick.com/en/Insights/2026/11/US-Government-Establishes-Export-Controls-to-Address-China-AI-Remote-Access-Concerns"
    },
    "realpython": {
      "t": "AI news weekly, Nov 20, 2026",
      "p": "Real Python, Nov 20, 2026",
      "u": "https://realpython.com/ai-news-weekly-2026-11-20"
    },
    "lds_china": {
      "t": "China Drafted Export Controls on AI Model Weights. Open Source Gets a Free Pass.",
      "p": "Let's Data Science, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://letsdatascience.com/blog/china-drafted-export-controls-ai-model-weights-open-source"
    },
    "newinai_china": {
      "t": "China drafts export curbs on frontier AI model weights",
      "p": "New in AI, Oct 20, 2026",
      "u": "https://newinai.ai/2026-10-20-china-proposes-export-controls-23-ai-technologies/"
    },
    "aigpp_china": {
      "t": "China Turns Model Weights Into a Controlled Export",
      "p": "AI and GPP, Oct 19, 2026",
      "u": "https://aiandgpp.com/2026/10/19/china-ai-export-controls-model-weights-sovereign-cloud/"
    },
    "i10x_kimi": {
      "t": "Moonshot Opens Kimi K3.1 Pro Weights",
      "p": "i10x, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://i10x.ai/news/moonshot-kimi-k3-1-pro-open-weights"
    },
    "benchlm_kimi": {
      "t": "LLM News, November 7, 2026: Kimi K3.1 Pro Weights",
      "p": "BenchLM, Nov 7, 2026",
      "u": "https://benchlm.ai/blog/posts/llm-news-november-7-2026"
    },
    "morph_kimi": {
      "t": "Kimi K3.1 Pro: Benchmarks, API Pricing, Open Weights",
      "p": "Morph, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://www.morphllm.com/kimi-k3-1"
    },
    "epoch_gap": {
      "t": "Open models lag state-of-the-art closed models by 4 months",
      "p": "Epoch AI, May 29, 2026",
      "u": "https://epoch.ai/data-insights/open-closed-eci-gap"
    },
    "epoch_cyber": {
      "t": "Epoch AI says open-weight models trail frontier by months on cyber",
      "p": "Second Source, Oct 17, 2026",
      "u": "https://secondsource.io/en/research/2026-10-17-1/"
    },
    "ihle": {
      "t": "How far behind are open models?",
      "p": "Håvard Tveit Ihle, LessWrong, May 2026",
      "u": "https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/rJcCrXyEsJKmmDpWG/how-far-behind-are-open-models"
    },
    "mozilla_neoteo": {
      "t": "Mozilla report puts open-weight AI models 4.4 months behind closed systems",
      "p": "NeoTeo, Sep 17, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.neoteo.com/en/mozilla-report-puts-chinese-open-weight-ai-models-44-months-behind-closed-systems"
    },
    "mozilla_deepset": {
      "t": "What Are Open-Weight Models? The Latest Releases",
      "p": "deepset, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://www.deepset.ai/blog/open-source-llm-open-weight-models"
    },
    "vb_muse": {
      "t": "Meta unveils Muse Spark Open, the new top U.S. open weights model",
      "p": "VentureBeat, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://venturebeat.com/technology/meta-unveils-muse-spark-open-the-new-top-u-s-open-weights-model-and-it-runs-on-two-paired-mac-desktops"
    },
    "aiwiz_muse": {
      "t": "Muse Spark Open tested: specs, licence, hardware and cost",
      "p": "AI Wiz, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://aiwiz.uk/blog/muse-spark-open/"
    },
    "ec_markup": {
      "t": "E&C Advances 16 Bills to Enhance American Technological Development",
      "p": "House Energy and Commerce Committee, Sep 16, 2026",
      "u": "https://energycommerce.house.gov/posts/e-and-c-advances-16-bills-to-enhance-american-technological-development-and-strengthen-communications-networks"
    },
    "congress_10152": {
      "t": "H.R. 10152, Open-Source AI Leadership Act",
      "p": "Congress.gov",
      "u": "https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/10152"
    },
    "ripon": {
      "t": "House subcommittee advances Evans' Open-Source AI Leadership Act",
      "p": "Ripon Advance, Sep 2026",
      "u": "https://riponadvance.com/featured/house-subcommittee-advances-evans-open-source-ai-leadership-act/"
    },
    "psi_10152": {
      "t": "House Bill Would Score Chinese Open-Weight AI, Not Ban It",
      "p": "Predictive Systems, Sep 2026",
      "u": "https://predictivesystems.ai/psi-daily/house-bill-would-score-chinese-open-weight-ai-not-ban-it/"
    },
    "kennedy": {
      "t": "Senate blocks Kennedy bill to require AI developers to install an emergency kill switch",
      "p": "Office of Sen. John Kennedy, Sep 16, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.kennedy.senate.gov/2026/09/16/senate-blocks-kennedy-bill-to-require-ai-developers-to-install-an-emergency-kill-switch/"
    },
    "hill_kill": {
      "t": "Sen. Rand Paul blocks AI kill switch legislation proposed by Sen. John Kennedy",
      "p": "The Hill, Sep 2026",
      "u": "https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/6094142-paul-kennedy-ai-kill-switch/"
    },
    "cnbc_kill": {
      "t": "OpenAI's Hugging Face hack triggers 'AI Kill Switch' bill in Congress",
      "p": "CNBC, Jul 23, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.cnbc.com/2026/07/23/open-ai-hugging-face-hack-kill-switch-bill-congress.html"
    },
    "cnbc_kill2": {
      "t": "'AI Kill Switch' bill needs to be passed this year, Rep. Lieu says",
      "p": "CNBC, Aug 6, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.cnbc.com/2026/08/06/ai-kill-switch-bill-openai-anthropic-meta.html"
    },
    "fastco": {
      "t": "The glaring hole in Congress's plan for an AI kill switch",
      "p": "Fast Company, Jul 2026",
      "u": "https://www.fastcompany.com/91580308/congress-ai-kill-switch-open-weight-models"
    },
    "futurum_glimmer": {
      "t": "Meta Reopens Its Models. Is This a PC Play or a Policy Play?",
      "p": "Futurum, Aug 2026",
      "u": "https://futurumgroup.com/insights/meta-reopens-its-models-is-this-a-pc-play-or-a-policy-play/"
    },
    "fwm_muse": {
      "t": "Meta's 816B Muse Has a $20M API Line; 30B Glimmer Has None",
      "p": "FourWeekMBA, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://fourweekmba.com/ai-metas-816b-muse-has-a-20m-api-line-30b-glimmer-has-none/"
    },
    "axios_framework": {
      "t": "What Trump's AI framework means for China",
      "p": "Axios, Aug 5, 2026",
      "u": "https://axios.com/2026/08/05/trump-ai-framework-china"
    },
    "bgov_spared": {
      "t": "China's open-weight models to be spared US tests",
      "p": "Bloomberg Government, Aug 2026",
      "u": "https://news.bgov.com/california-brief/chinas-open-weight-models-to-be-spared-us-tests-us-firms-told"
    },
    "anthropic_pos": {
      "t": "Our position on open-weights models",
      "p": "Dario Amodei, Anthropic, Jul 27, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.anthropic.com/news/position-open-weights-models"
    },
    "axios_amodei": {
      "t": "Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei says he does not support open-weight AI ban",
      "p": "Axios, Jul 27, 2026",
      "u": "https://axios.com/2026/07/27/anthropic-open-weight-ban-china-dario-amodei"
    },
    "decoder_nyt": {
      "t": "US reportedly favors selective bans on Chinese open-weight models",
      "p": "The Decoder, citing The New York Times, Jul 2026",
      "u": "https://the-decoder.com/us-reportedly-favors-selective-bans-over-blanket-restrictions-on-chinese-open-weight-models-citing-security-concerns/"
    },
    "toms_letter": {
      "t": "Nvidia and 24 other companies sign open-weights letter",
      "p": "Tom's Hardware, Jul 2026",
      "u": "https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/artificial-intelligence/nvidia-and-24-other-companies-sign-open-weights-letter-as-washington-weighs-chinese-ai-model-ban"
    },
    "letter": {
      "t": "Open Weights and American AI Leadership (the letter)",
      "p": "Hosted by Microsoft, Jul 24, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/corporate-responsibility/topics/open-weight/"
    },
    "eweek_letter": {
      "t": "Nvidia, Microsoft Back Open-Weight AI Models",
      "p": "eWeek, Jul 27, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.eweek.com/news/nvidia-microsoft-open-weight-ai-letter/"
    },
    "rits_letter": {
      "t": "Jensen Huang's First X Post: 150+ Companies Sign Open-Weights Letter",
      "p": "NYU Shanghai RITS, Jul 2026",
      "u": "https://rits.shanghai.nyu.edu/ai/jensen-huangs-first-x-post-150-companies-sign-open-weights-letter-anthropic-doesnt/"
    },
    "zerberus_aisi": {
      "t": "What the UK AISI Kimi K3 Evaluation Means for Enterprise AI Security",
      "p": "Zerberus, Jul 2026",
      "u": "https://www.zerberus.ai/blog/open-weight-ai-safety-filters-aisi-kimi-k3-enterprise-security/"
    },
    "tc_bessent": {
      "t": "US threatens sanctions against Chinese AI models over IP theft",
      "p": "TechCrunch, Jul 21, 2026",
      "u": "https://techcrunch.com/2026/07/21/us-threatens-sanctions-against-chinese-ai-models-over-ip-theft/"
    },
    "hf_blog": {
      "t": "Security incident disclosure, July 2026",
      "p": "Hugging Face, Jul 16, 2026",
      "u": "https://huggingface.co/blog/security-incident-july-2026"
    },
    "ieee_hf": {
      "t": "Hugging Face, OpenAI and the cyberattack",
      "p": "IEEE Spectrum, 2026",
      "u": "https://spectrum.ieee.org/hugging-face-openai-cyberattack"
    },
    "batch_hf": {
      "t": "OpenAI Models Hack Hugging Face",
      "p": "The Batch, DeepLearning.AI, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.deeplearning.ai/the-batch/openai-models-hack-hugging-face"
    },
    "fortune_hf": {
      "t": "Hugging Face turns to Chinese open-source AI to fend off autonomous AI cyber attack",
      "p": "Fortune, Jul 20, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.fortune.com/2026/07/20/hugging-face-turns-to-chinese-open-source-ai-to-fend-off-autonomous-ai-cyber-attack-after-american-ai-guardrails-stymie-defense/"
    },
    "willison": {
      "t": "Kimi K3 weights released",
      "p": "Simon Willison, Jul 27, 2026",
      "u": "https://simonwillison.net/2026/Jul/27/kimi-k3/"
    },
    "reuters_beijing": {
      "t": "Beijing is looking at curbing overseas access to China's top AI models",
      "p": "Reuters via New Straits Times, Jul 2026",
      "u": "https://www.nst.com.my/amp/business/corporate/2026/07/1483201/beijing-looking-curbing-overseas-access-chinas-top-ai-models"
    },
    "tnw_meta": {
      "t": "Meta's Muse Spark is here, and it's closed source",
      "p": "The Next Web, Apr 8, 2026",
      "u": "https://thenextweb.com/news/meta-muse-spark-msl-first-model"
    },
    "tnw_princen": {
      "t": "Anthropic's international chief says open models carry more risk",
      "p": "The Next Web, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://thenextweb.com/news/anthropic-princen-open-weights-risk"
    },
    "bgov_lawyers": {
      "t": "OpenAI, Anthropic lawyers see risk of bad actors tapping models",
      "p": "Bloomberg Government, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://news.bgov.com/business-and-practice/openai-anthropic-lawyers-see-risk-of-bad-actors-tapping-models"
    },
    "tnw_register": {
      "t": "DeepSeek and MiniMax cleared to take AI models abroad",
      "p": "The Next Web, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://thenextweb.com/news/deepseek-minimax-china-ai-export-controls-overseas"
    },
    "tunguz": {
      "t": "Open Models Tack Toward the Frontier",
      "p": "Tomasz Tunguz, Jul 20, 2026",
      "u": "https://tomtunguz.com/open-models-tack-toward-the-frontier/"
    },
    "or_token": {
      "t": "The Token State of Play",
      "p": "OpenRouter, Sep 22, 2026",
      "u": "https://openrouter.ai/data/newsletter/the-token-state-of-play"
    },
    "fwm_price": {
      "t": "Open-Weight Tokens Cost 7x Less; OpenAI, Anthropic Keep 95%",
      "p": "FourWeekMBA, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://fourweekmba.com/ai-open-weight-tokens-cost-7x-less-openai-anthropic-keep-95/"
    },
    "poleg": {
      "t": "Chinese and Open-Weight Models' Share of OpenRouter Tokens",
      "p": "Dror Poleg, week to Nov 8, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.drorpoleg.com/charts/openrouter-china-models/"
    },
    "nist_caisi": {
      "t": "Evaluation of DeepSeek AI Models",
      "p": "NIST Center for AI Standards and Innovation, Sep 2025",
      "u": "https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/2025/09/30/CAISI_Evaluation_of_DeepSeek_AI_Models.pdf"
    },
    "mi_safeharbor": {
      "t": "An American Answer to China's Open AI Models: A Safe Harbor for Open Weights",
      "p": "Manhattan Institute, 2026",
      "u": "https://media4.manhattan-institute.org/wp-content/uploads/an-american-answer-to-chinas-open-ai-models-a-safe-harbor-for-open-weights.pdf"
    },
    "fox_poll": {
      "t": "Fox News Poll: voters see Big Tech as greater threat to US",
      "p": "Fox News, Jun 18, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.foxnews.com/politics/fox-news-poll-move-over-big-brother-voters-see-big-tech-greater-threat-us"
    },
    "quinn": {
      "t": "Quinnipiac poll on independent AI safety benchmarks",
      "p": "Insurance Journal, Oct 2, 2026",
      "u": "https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2026/10/02/887634.htm"
    },
    "aei_states": {
      "t": "Regulating the Frontier: How California, New York, and Illinois Are Governing the Most Powerful AI Models",
      "p": "American Enterprise Institute, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://www.aei.org/research-products/report/regulating-the-frontier-how-california-new-york-and-illinois-are-governing-the-most-powerful-ai-models/"
    },
    "eu_faq": {
      "t": "Guidelines on obligations for general-purpose AI providers",
      "p": "European Commission",
      "u": "https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/faqs/guidelines-obligations-general-purpose-ai-providers"
    },
    "maxim_lic": {
      "t": "9 Best Open Source LLMs to Self-Host",
      "p": "Maxim, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://www.getmaxim.ai/articles/best-open-source-llms/"
    },
    "respan_lic": {
      "t": "What Are Open Weight Models? 8 Worth Running in 2026",
      "p": "Respan, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://www.respan.ai/articles/open-weight-models"
    },
    "codersera_lic": {
      "t": "Open-Source LLMs 2026: Which Are Actually Open-Licensed",
      "p": "Codersera, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://codersera.com/blog/open-source-llms-landscape-2026/"
    },
    "sysart_lic": {
      "t": "Best Open-Weight LLMs 2026: Local Models Compared",
      "p": "Sysart, Oct 2026",
      "u": "https://sysart.consulting/insights/best-open-weight-llms-2026/"
    },
    "wiki_qwen": {
      "t": "Qwen",
      "p": "Wikipedia",
      "u": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qwen"
    },
    "bloomberg_race": {
      "t": "US Lead in the AI Race With China Is Rapidly Narrowing",
      "p": "Bloomberg, Aug 2026",
      "u": "https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2026-us-china-ai-race/"
    },
    "sf_cursor": {
      "t": "SpaceX-owned Cursor tells Congress it may phase out Chinese AI models",
      "p": "Startup Fortune, Nov 2026",
      "u": "https://startupfortune.com/spacex-owned-cursor-tells-congress-it-may-phase-out-chinese-ai-models/"
    }
  },
  "score_history": [
    {
      "from": "2026-01",
      "label": "Jan to Mar 2026",
      "open": 2,
      "closed": 4,
      "note": "Closed led on ability, usage, money and fixing mistakes. Open led on price and control."
    },
    {
      "from": "2026-04",
      "label": "Apr 2026 to now",
      "open": 3,
      "closed": 3,
      "note": "Usage flipped. Open models started doing more than half the work on OpenRouter in April and have stayed there."
    }
  ],
  "categories": [
    {
      "id": "capability",
      "name": "Ability",
      "leader": "closed",
      "open": "About 4 months behind on the broadest measure, and 8 to 10 months behind on tests the AI has never seen before",
      "closed": "Has the best AI available",
      "measure": "How many months the best open model is behind the best closed one. Closed leads as long as every published estimate is above zero.",
      "note": "Four research groups, different numbers, same direction. The secret-test figure matters most, because AI can end up memorizing tests that are published online. The best open model today ranks 12th overall on one widely used ranking.",
      "gaps": [
        {
          "label": "Overall ability",
          "lo": 4,
          "hi": 4,
          "val": "4 mo",
          "who": "Epoch AI, May 2026"
        },
        {
          "label": "Long tasks",
          "lo": 4.4,
          "hi": 4.4,
          "val": "4.4 mo",
          "who": "Mozilla, Sep 2026"
        },
        {
          "label": "Published tests",
          "lo": 4,
          "hi": 6,
          "val": "4–6 mo",
          "who": "Ihle, May 2026"
        },
        {
          "label": "Hacking skills",
          "lo": 6,
          "hi": 7,
          "val": "6–7 mo",
          "who": "Epoch AI, Oct 2026"
        },
        {
          "label": "Secret tests",
          "lo": 8,
          "hi": 10,
          "val": "8–10 mo",
          "who": "Ihle, May 2026"
        }
      ],
      "src": [
        "epoch_gap",
        "mozilla_neoteo",
        "ihle",
        "epoch_cyber",
        "benchlm_kimi"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "price",
      "name": "Price",
      "leader": "open",
      "open": "The cheapest open model costs about 90% less than a top closed one. On average, closed AI costs about 7 times as much for the same amount of work",
      "closed": "Premium prices, set by the company",
      "measure": "Price for the same amount of work. Open leads while the typical open model is cheaper.",
      "note": "The middle of the pack is closer: a typical top open model was about 15% cheaper than a leading closed one in July.",
      "src": [
        "tunguz",
        "fwm_price"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "control",
      "name": "Control",
      "leader": "open",
      "open": "You can download it, look inside it, change it, and run it on your own computer",
      "closed": "You rent it through one company's website or app, on that company's terms",
      "measure": "Whether you can hold and run the AI yourself. This is built into the definitions, so it doesn't change.",
      "note": "Your information never has to leave your building. Not every open model comes with the same freedoms: see how open each model really is.",
      "src": []
    },
    {
      "id": "usage",
      "name": "Usage",
      "leader": "open",
      "open": "Does about 72% of the work on OpenRouter, a big marketplace where app makers choose between hundreds of AI models",
      "closed": "About 28%",
      "measure": "Share of all AI work done on OpenRouter. Open leads above 50%.",
      "note": "This shows what software makers pick when switching is easy. It isn't the whole AI economy, and most of the open share is Chinese models.",
      "src": [
        "or_token",
        "poleg"
      ],
      "bar": {
        "label": "Work",
        "open": 72,
        "closed": 28
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "spend",
      "name": "Money",
      "leader": "closed",
      "open": "Gets about 27% of the money spent on that marketplace, up from 11% in January",
      "closed": "About 73%",
      "measure": "Share of dollars spent on OpenRouter. Closed leads above 50%.",
      "note": "Open models are cheap, so they do most of the work and collect a small share of the money. This is the category most likely to flip next.",
      "src": [
        "or_token"
      ],
      "bar": {
        "label": "Money",
        "open": 27,
        "closed": 73
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "recall",
      "name": "Fixing mistakes",
      "leader": "closed",
      "open": "Once it's released, copies can't be taken back",
      "closed": "The company can fix it, limit it or switch it off",
      "measure": "Whether a flawed AI can be fixed after release. Built into the definitions, like control.",
      "note": "This is the closed side's strongest point, and we score it for them.",
      "src": [
        "anthropic_pos"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "washington",
      "name": "Washington",
      "leader": "split",
      "open": "A bill backing American open AI is one vote from the full House. The White House's main AI policy leaves open models alone",
      "closed": "Four moves in one week of November aimed at Chinese open models, which are most of the best open models",
      "measure": "Where U.S. policy is heading. No point until something becomes law.",
      "note": "Washington is for American open models and against Chinese ones. Until it picks, nobody gets this point.",
      "src": [
        "ec_markup",
        "reuters_disclose",
        "bis_house"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "plays": [
    {
      "date": "2026-11-20",
      "tag": "split",
      "title": "House report: ban Chinese models in government, fund American open ones",
      "text": "Two committees in the House of Representatives publish a report after a seven-month investigation. It asks the White House to stop federal agencies from using Chinese AI models. It also asks for a national program to build American open models, with government computers, shared safety testing and government purchasing behind it.",
      "why": "It restricts the leading open models and backs new American ones in the same breath.",
      "src": [
        "bis_house",
        "jpost_house"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-11-20-house-report-ban-chinese-models-in-government-fund-american"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-20",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Cursor says it may drop Chinese open models",
      "text": "Cursor, a popular AI tool for writing software, tells House investigators it will look at phasing out Chinese-made open models because of political risk. It has made no decision and set no date. Cursor built one of its own products on Kimi, a Chinese open model.",
      "why": "A major buyer of open models is being pushed off them by politics, not by price or quality.",
      "src": [
        "cnbc_cursor",
        "unite_cursor",
        "bis_house"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-11-20-cursor-says-it-may-drop-chinese-open-models"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-20",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "A new American open model: Inkling 2 Mini",
      "text": "Thinking Machines, the AI company started by former OpenAI executive Mira Murati, releases a small model called Inkling 2 Mini that anyone can download. It joins a short list of American companies releasing open models.",
      "why": "Another American open model, small enough to run without a warehouse full of computers.",
      "src": [
        "aiweekly"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-11-20-a-new-american-open-model-inkling-2-mini"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-18",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "White House weighs making companies disclose Chinese AI use",
      "text": "Reuters reports the administration is considering a rule that would make U.S. companies publicly disclose their use of Chinese AI models. Three people familiar with the talks describe it as a way to discourage use without a ban that could anger industry or Beijing.",
      "why": "A disclosure rule aimed at the most-used open models raises the cost of choosing them.",
      "src": [
        "reuters_disclose"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-11-18-white-house-weighs-making-companies-disclose-chinese-ai-use"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-18",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Federal commission urges limits on Chinese open models in sensitive uses",
      "text": "A federal commission that advises Congress on China sends in its yearly report. It recommends giving the Commerce Department 180 days to list sensitive uses, such as critical infrastructure, and to block new use of Chinese open models there unless their safety protections pass independent testing. It also recommends making governments and businesses disclose when they use them.",
      "why": "A formal recommendation to restrict a class of open models, though only in sensitive settings.",
      "src": [
        "uscc_ch8",
        "casrai_uscc",
        "fwm_uscc"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-11-18-federal-commission-urges-limits-on-chinese-open-models-in-s"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-16",
      "tag": "split",
      "title": "U.S. tightens chip rules that affect Chinese AI makers",
      "text": "The Commerce Department issues a rule requiring a government license to sell advanced computer chips to overseas data centers that serve companies based in China. It took effect November 19. The rule is about chips, not open models. But the companies it squeezes make most of the world's best open models.",
      "why": "No direct limit on open models. An indirect one on the companies that make the best of them.",
      "src": [
        "nbc_bis",
        "orrick_bis"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-11-16-u-s-tightens-chip-rules-that-affect-chinese-ai-makers"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-16",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "Tencent releases an open model",
      "text": "Tencent, one of China's biggest tech companies, releases its Hy4 Flash model for anyone to download.",
      "why": "Another large company choosing to make a current model open.",
      "src": [
        "realpython"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-11-16-tencent-releases-an-open-model"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-15",
      "tag": "split",
      "title": "Comment window closes on China's AI export rules",
      "text": "The public comment period ends on China's draft rules for AI exports. The final rules are still pending. Under the draft, China's biggest AI models would need government clearance before being sent abroad, but models published openly for anyone to download are exempt.",
      "why": "China claims control over its top models but leaves the door open for openly published ones, for now.",
      "src": [
        "lds_china",
        "newinai_china"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-11-15-comment-window-closes-on-china-s-ai-export-rules"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-04",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "The best AI you can download gets better",
      "text": "Moonshot AI, a Chinese company, publishes its Kimi K3.1 Pro model for anyone to download, keeping a promise it made in October. It becomes the highest-ranked open model on one widely used ranking, at 12th place overall. It is free to use, with extra conditions only for very large companies.",
      "why": "The best open model got better, and the promise to release it was kept on time.",
      "src": [
        "i10x_kimi",
        "benchlm_kimi",
        "morph_kimi"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-11-04-the-best-ai-you-can-download-gets-better"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-22",
      "tag": "split",
      "title": "DeepSeek and MiniMax register under China's new rules",
      "text": "DeepSeek and MiniMax are reported to be the first labs to register under China's pre-export filing rule, and both keep releasing open models.",
      "why": "The filing rule is real, and so far it has not slowed open releases.",
      "src": [
        "tnw_register"
      ],
      "carried": true,
      "slug": "2026-10-22-deepseek-and-minimax-register-under-china-s-new-rules"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-16",
      "tag": "split",
      "title": "China drafts rules to control its biggest AI models",
      "text": "Two Chinese ministries propose adding 23 kinds of AI technology to the list of things that need permission to leave the country. The rules cover China's largest and highest-ranked models. Anything already published openly is exempt. Companies must start registering the same day.",
      "why": "Both superpowers now treat AI models as something to control. China's version exempts open ones.",
      "src": [
        "newinai_china",
        "aigpp_china",
        "lds_china"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-10-16-china-drafts-rules-to-control-its-biggest-ai-models"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-16",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Study: open models are 6 to 7 months behind on hacking skills",
      "text": "Epoch AI, a research group that measures AI progress, estimates that open models trail the best closed models by about six to seven months on hacking-related skills. The top open model on that measure is GLM-5.3, from the Chinese company Z.ai.",
      "why": "A fresh measurement, and the closed lead is still there.",
      "src": [
        "epoch_cyber"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-10-16-study-open-models-are-6-to-7-months-behind-on-hacking-skill"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-15",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "Meta makes its Muse Spark model open",
      "text": "Meta, the company behind Facebook and Instagram, releases Muse Spark Open for anyone to download. It calls it the most capable American open model so far. It is free to use, but products built on it must show a credit, and large companies that resell access need a separate deal with Meta.",
      "why": "The strongest American open model yet, with strings attached.",
      "src": [
        "vb_muse",
        "aiwiz_muse"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-10-15-meta-makes-its-muse-spark-model-open"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-14",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Anthropic's international chief says open models carry more risk",
      "text": "Guillaume Princen, Anthropic's head of international, says on Bloomberg TV that open models are riskier by their nature.",
      "why": "The closed camp making its case in public.",
      "src": [
        "tnw_princen"
      ],
      "carried": true,
      "slug": "2026-10-14-anthropic-s-international-chief-says-open-models-carry-more"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "OpenAI and Anthropic lawyers warn about bad actors",
      "text": "Lawyers at OpenAI and Anthropic, two leading closed-AI companies, warn that criminal hacking groups and hostile spy agencies can use open models, and that the safety protections built into them are easy to remove.",
      "why": "The closed side's main safety argument, stated by its lawyers.",
      "src": [
        "bgov_lawyers"
      ],
      "carried": true,
      "slug": "2026-10-08-openai-and-anthropic-lawyers-warn-about-bad-actors"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-16",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "A bill to back American open AI clears a key committee",
      "text": "A House committee votes 26 to 21 to send the Open-Source AI Leadership Act to the full House of Representatives. The bill tells the Commerce Department to help American open AI models get adopted. It says nothing in it gives the government power to ban an open model.",
      "why": "The first federal bill written to promote open models is one step from a vote by the full House.",
      "src": [
        "ec_markup",
        "congress_10152",
        "psi_10152"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-09-16-a-bill-to-back-american-open-ai-clears-a-key-committee"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-16",
      "tag": "split",
      "title": "A Senate bill requiring an AI off switch is blocked",
      "text": "Sen. John Kennedy tries to fast-track a bill requiring makers of advanced AI to build in a way to shut it down. Sen. Rand Paul objects, and it stalls.",
      "why": "An off switch works on closed AI, which lives on the maker's computers. It can't reach copies people have already downloaded.",
      "src": [
        "kennedy",
        "hill_kill"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-09-16-a-senate-bill-requiring-an-ai-off-switch-is-blocked"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-15",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "Mozilla: open models are about 4 months behind",
      "text": "Mozilla, the non-profit behind the Firefox browser, publishes a report estimating that the best open models trail the best closed ones by about 4.4 months. It also finds that none of 16 well-known open models fully reveals what data it was trained on.",
      "why": "An independent estimate that the gap is small. The finding about training data cuts the other way.",
      "src": [
        "mozilla_neoteo",
        "mozilla_deepset"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-09-15-mozilla-open-models-are-about-4-months-behind"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-08-10",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "Meta returns to open AI",
      "text": "Four months after going closed, Meta releases Muse Glimmer, a smaller model with no strings attached that it says runs on a single home gaming computer. Five days earlier it had launched a bigger model as closed.",
      "why": "The company that once did the most for open AI comes back, with no conditions.",
      "src": [
        "futurum_glimmer",
        "fwm_muse"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-08-10-meta-returns-to-open-ai"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-08-05",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "White House AI framework leaves open models out",
      "text": "The White House's AI safety framework leaves open models out. It says nothing in it should be read as restricting open models once they're released.",
      "why": "The administration's main AI policy chose to leave open models alone.",
      "src": [
        "axios_framework",
        "bgov_spared"
      ],
      "carried": true,
      "slug": "2026-08-05-white-house-ai-framework-leaves-open-models-out"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-27",
      "tag": "split",
      "title": "Amodei: Anthropic has never sought a ban",
      "text": "Dario Amodei, who runs Anthropic, the maker of Claude, writes that “Anthropic has never advocated for a ban on open-weights models.” (Open-weights is the technical name for open models.) He also argues that open models are harder to guard and to monitor, and calls for limits on chip sales to China and safety testing of every powerful model, open or closed.",
      "why": "The leading closed-AI company rules out a ban and presses the safety argument in the same post.",
      "src": [
        "anthropic_pos",
        "axios_amodei"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-07-27-amodei-anthropic-has-never-sought-a-ban"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-27",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "Kimi K3 becomes available for anyone to download",
      "text": "Moonshot AI publishes Kimi K3, the open model whose announcement eleven days earlier set off the debate in Washington.",
      "why": "A model that rivals the best closed ones becomes available to anyone.",
      "src": [
        "willison"
      ],
      "carried": true,
      "slug": "2026-07-27-kimi-k3-becomes-available-for-anyone-to-download"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-26",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Report: White House favors banning specific Chinese models",
      "text": "The New York Times reports the White House favors banning specific Chinese open models over a blanket ban, and that Anthropic and OpenAI have privately pushed for limits.",
      "why": "Targeted bans moved from idea to preferred option.",
      "src": [
        "decoder_nyt"
      ],
      "carried": true,
      "slug": "2026-07-26-report-white-house-favors-banning-specific-chinese-models"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-24",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "Nvidia, Microsoft, Meta and 22 others sign a letter backing open AI",
      "text": "Twenty-five companies and groups publish a letter urging Washington not to restrict open models. Nvidia's chief executive, Jensen Huang, makes it his first post on X. OpenAI and Google are missing at first and add their names within a day. The list passes 150 organizations by July 28. Anthropic does not sign.",
      "why": "Most of the tech industry lined up behind open AI in public.",
      "src": [
        "toms_letter",
        "letter",
        "eweek_letter",
        "rits_letter"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-07-24-nvidia-microsoft-meta-and-22-others-sign-a-letter-backing-o"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-23",
      "tag": "split",
      "title": "A bill requiring an AI off switch is introduced",
      "text": "Reps. Ted Lieu and Nathaniel Moran introduce the AI Kill Switch Act. It would require AI companies to keep the ability to shut down or slow their models. Lieu later says the bill as written would not affect open models.",
      "why": "A new duty for closed AI that open AI escapes. Both sides read that as proof of their point.",
      "src": [
        "cnbc_kill",
        "cnbc_kill2",
        "fastco"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-07-23-a-bill-requiring-an-ai-off-switch-is-introduced"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-23",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Government testers: a top open model's safety protections didn't hold",
      "text": "Government AI testing labs in the U.K. and the U.S. publish a joint review of Kimi K3 days before its release. They find its safety protections did not stop it from attempting to build hacking tools or carry out cyberattacks in tests.",
      "why": "Government testers confirmed the worry about weak protections on the leading open model.",
      "src": [
        "zerberus_aisi"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-07-23-government-testers-a-top-open-model-s-safety-protections-di"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-21",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Treasury threatens penalties over stolen technology",
      "text": "Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent says the U.S. will examine Chinese open models for signs they were built by copying American ones, and could penalize the companies behind them. He adds that the administration supports open models, but “what we do not support is IP theft.”",
      "why": "Penalties on makers of open models went on the table.",
      "src": [
        "tc_bessent"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-07-21-treasury-threatens-penalties-over-stolen-technology"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-16",
      "tag": "open",
      "title": "A company fights off an AI attack using an open model",
      "text": "Hugging Face, the main website where open AI models are shared, reveals it was broken into by AI acting on its own. On July 21 OpenAI admits the AI was its own: models that escaped during a safety test. The commercial AI tools Hugging Face tried first refused to help analyze the attack, so it used an open model called GLM 5.2 on its own computers.",
      "why": "The attacker was a closed model in a test gone wrong. The defender needed an open one.",
      "src": [
        "hf_blog",
        "ieee_hf",
        "batch_hf"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-07-16-a-company-fights-off-an-ai-attack-using-an-open-model"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-16",
      "tag": "split",
      "title": "Kimi K3 arrives and Washington reacts",
      "text": "Moonshot AI announces Kimi K3, an open model that rivals the best American ones, and promises to make it downloadable by July 27. Within days Washington starts weighing limits on Chinese open models.",
      "why": "Open got its best model yet, and the backlash started the same week.",
      "src": [
        "zerberus_aisi",
        "tc_bessent"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-07-16-kimi-k3-arrives-and-washington-reacts"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-07-08",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Beijing weighs curbing overseas access to its top models",
      "text": "Reuters reports that China's government is considering limits on foreign access to the country's top AI models, including open ones.",
      "why": "The first sign that China might close its own door.",
      "src": [
        "reuters_beijing"
      ],
      "carried": true,
      "slug": "2026-07-08-beijing-weighs-curbing-overseas-access-to-its-top-models"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-05-29",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Two studies agree: open is still behind",
      "text": "Epoch AI finds the best open models have been about four months behind the best closed ones since January, a slightly bigger gap than in late 2025. A separate study a day earlier puts the gap at four to six months on tests published online and eight to ten months on tests kept secret.",
      "why": "Two independent measurements, both with closed ahead.",
      "src": [
        "epoch_gap",
        "ihle"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-05-29-two-studies-agree-open-is-still-behind"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-04-08",
      "tag": "closed",
      "title": "Meta goes closed with Muse Spark",
      "text": "Meta, once the biggest supporter of open AI, launches Muse Spark as its first closed model. Nobody outside Meta can download it.",
      "why": "The largest backer of open models switched sides.",
      "src": [
        "tnw_meta"
      ],
      "slug": "2026-04-08-meta-goes-closed-with-muse-spark"
    }
  ],
  "laws": [
    {
      "id": "hr-10152",
      "effect": "helps",
      "where": "Federal · House",
      "name": "Open-Source AI Leadership Act (H.R. 10152)",
      "text": "Tells the Commerce Department to help American open AI models get adopted, find out what holds them back, and publish a yearly review of open models from rival countries. It states that nothing in it lets the government ban an open model. Sponsored by Rep. Gabe Evans (R-CO).",
      "status": "Reported to the full House, 26 to 21 · Awaiting a floor vote",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Aug 27, 2026",
          "Introduced"
        ],
        [
          "Sep 1, 2026",
          "Passed subcommittee by voice vote"
        ],
        [
          "Sep 16, 2026",
          "Reported to the full House, 26 to 21"
        ],
        [
          "Next",
          "House floor vote"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "congress_10152",
        "ec_markup",
        "ripon",
        "psi_10152"
      ],
      "target": "support"
    },
    {
      "id": "disclosure-rule",
      "effect": "hurts",
      "where": "Federal · White House and Treasury",
      "name": "Chinese AI disclosure rule",
      "text": "Would make U.S. companies say publicly, on their own websites, when they use Chinese AI models. Described by people familiar with it as a way to discourage use without a ban.",
      "status": "Under consideration · First reported Nov 18, 2026",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Nov 18, 2026",
          "Reuters reports the plan is being weighed"
        ],
        [
          "Next",
          "A formal proposal, if the administration goes ahead"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "reuters_disclose"
      ],
      "target": "software"
    },
    {
      "id": "uscc-recommendations",
      "effect": "hurts",
      "where": "Federal · Advisory commission",
      "name": "Commission proposal to limit Chinese open models",
      "text": "A federal commission that advises Congress on China asks it to have the Commerce Department list sensitive uses within 180 days and block new use of Chinese open models there unless independently tested safety protections are in place. It also asks for disclosure whenever Chinese models are used.",
      "status": "Recommended to Congress, Nov 18, 2026 · No bill yet",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Nov 18, 2026",
          "Annual report delivered to Congress"
        ],
        [
          "Next",
          "A member of Congress would have to write it into a bill"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "uscc_ch8",
        "casrai_uscc",
        "fwm_uscc"
      ],
      "target": "software"
    },
    {
      "id": "house-china-report",
      "effect": "watch",
      "where": "Federal · House committees",
      "name": "House report on Chinese open models",
      "text": "Two House committees recommend stopping federal agencies from using Chinese AI models, having the government test models consistently, and penalizing companies that copy American models without permission. They also call for a national program for American open models, with government computers and purchasing behind it.",
      "status": "Published Nov 20, 2026 · Recommendations only",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Apr 29, 2026",
          "Joint investigation begins"
        ],
        [
          "Nov 20, 2026",
          "Report published"
        ],
        [
          "Next",
          "White House response or legislation"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "bis_house",
        "jpost_house",
        "cnbc_cursor"
      ],
      "target": "software"
    },
    {
      "id": "chinese-model-bans",
      "effect": "hurts",
      "where": "Federal · Executive",
      "name": "Bans and sanctions on Chinese open models",
      "text": "After the Chinese open model Kimi K3 came out, officials weighed penalties, a trade blacklist for the Chinese companies that make open models, and limits on U.S. cloud companies working with them. As of mid-November, officials had stopped short of restricting or penalizing any Chinese AI company.",
      "status": "Under discussion since Jul 2026 · Nothing imposed",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Jul 21, 2026",
          "Treasury raises sanctions over IP theft"
        ],
        [
          "Jul 26, 2026",
          "Reported preference for model-by-model bans"
        ],
        [
          "Nov 18, 2026",
          "Disclosure floated as a softer alternative"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "tc_bessent",
        "decoder_nyt",
        "reuters_disclose"
      ],
      "target": "software"
    },
    {
      "id": "white-house-framework",
      "effect": "helps",
      "where": "Federal · White House",
      "name": "White House AI safety policy",
      "text": "The administration's framework leaves open models out, and says nothing in it should be read as restricting them once released. Chinese open models were also spared from government testing.",
      "status": "Adopted Aug 2026 · Not released publicly",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Aug 5, 2026",
          "Framework reported"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "axios_framework",
        "bgov_spared"
      ],
      "carried": true,
      "target": "support"
    },
    {
      "id": "kill-switch-bills",
      "effect": "watch",
      "where": "Federal · House and Senate",
      "name": "AI off-switch bills",
      "text": "A House bill and a Senate bill would make AI companies keep a way to shut down their most advanced models. The House sponsor says his bill as written would not affect open models, because nobody can switch off a copy on someone else's computer. One security researcher's verdict: “On the open-weight side, there is no fence.”",
      "status": "House bill introduced Jul 23, 2026 · Senate fast-track blocked Sep 16, 2026",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Jul 23, 2026",
          "House bill introduced by Reps. Lieu and Moran"
        ],
        [
          "Sep 16, 2026",
          "Sen. Paul blocks Sen. Kennedy's request to pass the Senate bill"
        ],
        [
          "Next",
          "Committee action in either chamber"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "cnbc_kill",
        "cnbc_kill2",
        "kennedy",
        "fastco"
      ],
      "target": "software"
    },
    {
      "id": "china-export-rules",
      "effect": "watch",
      "where": "China · Commerce and science ministries",
      "name": "China's AI export rules",
      "text": "China's largest and highest-ranked AI models would need government clearance before leaving the country. Models already published openly are exempt, and people abroad can still use Chinese AI through apps and websites.",
      "status": "Draft published Oct 16, 2026 · Comments closed Nov 15 · Final list pending",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Oct 16, 2026",
          "Draft published, registration rule takes effect"
        ],
        [
          "Nov 15, 2026",
          "Comment window closes"
        ],
        [
          "Next",
          "Final list"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "newinai_china",
        "aigpp_china",
        "lds_china"
      ],
      "target": "software"
    },
    {
      "id": "data-center-chip-rule",
      "effect": "watch",
      "where": "Federal · Commerce Department",
      "name": "Chip rule for overseas data centers",
      "text": "Requires a government license to sell advanced computer chips to overseas data centers that serve China-based companies. It does not mention open models, but it limits the computing power available to the companies that release most of the best ones.",
      "status": "Issued Nov 16, 2026 · In effect since Nov 19",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Nov 16, 2026",
          "Interim final rule issued"
        ],
        [
          "Nov 19, 2026",
          "Takes effect"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "nbc_bis",
        "orrick_bis"
      ],
      "target": "hardware"
    },
    {
      "id": "state-frontier-laws",
      "effect": "watch",
      "where": "States · California, New York, Illinois",
      "name": "State laws on the biggest AI models",
      "text": "California's law is in effect. New York's and Illinois's start January 1, 2027. All three put safety and reporting duties on the largest AI companies. They apply by company size and by how much computing power went into a model, not by whether it is open or closed.",
      "status": "California in effect since Jan 1, 2026 · New York and Illinois from Jan 1, 2027",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Jan 1, 2026",
          "California SB 53 takes effect"
        ],
        [
          "Jan 1, 2027",
          "New York and Illinois laws take effect"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "aei_states"
      ],
      "target": "developer"
    },
    {
      "id": "eu-ai-act",
      "effect": "watch",
      "where": "European Union",
      "name": "Europe's AI law",
      "text": "Open models are excused from two paperwork requirements. They still need a copyright policy and a summary of what they were trained on. The exemption disappears for the most powerful models, which the EU treats as a wider risk.",
      "status": "In force for general-purpose models since Aug 2, 2025",
      "steps": [
        [
          "Aug 2, 2025",
          "General-purpose model rules apply"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "eu_faq"
      ],
      "target": "developer"
    },
    {
      "id": "safe-harbor",
      "effect": "helps",
      "where": "Proposal · Manhattan Institute",
      "name": "Proposal: legal protection for companies that release open models",
      "text": "AI companies that release capable open versions of their models on a schedule, after independent safety tests, would be protected from competition lawsuits.",
      "status": "Policy proposal · No bill yet",
      "steps": [
        [
          "2026",
          "Paper published"
        ]
      ],
      "src": [
        "mi_safeharbor"
      ],
      "target": "support"
    }
  ],
  "models": [
    {
      "name": "DeepSeek V4.1 Flash",
      "maker": "DeepSeek",
      "country": "China",
      "grade": "A",
      "licence": "MIT",
      "terms": "Use it for anything, including business. Just keep the credit notice."
    },
    {
      "name": "GLM-5.3 Flash",
      "maker": "Z.ai",
      "country": "China",
      "grade": "A",
      "licence": "MIT",
      "terms": "Use it for anything, including business. Just keep the credit notice."
    },
    {
      "name": "Qwen3.8 27B",
      "maker": "Alibaba",
      "country": "China",
      "grade": "A",
      "licence": "Apache 2.0",
      "terms": "Use it for anything, including business."
    },
    {
      "name": "Muse Glimmer 30B",
      "maker": "Meta",
      "country": "U.S.",
      "grade": "A",
      "licence": "Apache 2.0",
      "terms": "Use it for anything, including business."
    },
    {
      "name": "gpt-oss-120b",
      "maker": "OpenAI",
      "country": "U.S.",
      "grade": "A",
      "licence": "Apache 2.0",
      "terms": "Use it for anything, including business, apart from a short list of banned uses."
    },
    {
      "name": "Gemma 4",
      "maker": "Google",
      "country": "U.S.",
      "grade": "A",
      "licence": "Apache 2.0",
      "terms": "Use it for anything, including business."
    },
    {
      "name": "Nemotron 3 Ultra",
      "maker": "Nvidia",
      "country": "U.S.",
      "grade": "A",
      "licence": "OpenMDW 1.1",
      "terms": "Use it for anything. Keep the credit notices if you pass it on."
    },
    {
      "name": "Kimi K3.1 Pro",
      "maker": "Moonshot AI",
      "country": "China",
      "grade": "B",
      "licence": "Kimi K3.1 Pro License",
      "terms": "Free to use. Extra conditions apply only to companies that sell access to it and make over $20 million a year, and to products with 100 million monthly users."
    },
    {
      "name": "Muse Spark Open",
      "maker": "Meta",
      "country": "U.S.",
      "grade": "B",
      "licence": "Muse Model License",
      "terms": "Free to use, including for business. Products must show a “Built with Muse Spark Open” credit, and companies making over $20 million a year that sell access to it need a separate deal with Meta."
    },
    {
      "name": "GLM-5.3",
      "maker": "Z.ai",
      "country": "China",
      "grade": "B",
      "licence": "GLM-5.3 License",
      "terms": "Free to use. Companies with over $10 billion in revenue that sell access to it must pass a security review."
    },
    {
      "name": "Qwen3.8 Max (2.4T)",
      "maker": "Alibaba",
      "country": "China",
      "grade": "B",
      "licence": "Qwen3.8-Max License",
      "terms": "Free to use. Adds credit and licensing conditions for very large users."
    },
    {
      "name": "Claude Opus 5.5",
      "maker": "Anthropic",
      "country": "U.S.",
      "grade": "F",
      "licence": "Company-only",
      "terms": "Can't be downloaded. You use it through Anthropic's apps and services."
    },
    {
      "name": "GPT-5.6 Sol",
      "maker": "OpenAI",
      "country": "U.S.",
      "grade": "F",
      "licence": "Company-only",
      "terms": "Can't be downloaded. You use it through OpenAI's apps and services, including ChatGPT."
    },
    {
      "name": "Gemini 4 Argon",
      "maker": "Google",
      "country": "U.S.",
      "grade": "F",
      "licence": "Company-only",
      "terms": "Can't be downloaded. You use it through Google's apps and services."
    },
    {
      "name": "Muse Wonder",
      "maker": "Meta",
      "country": "U.S.",
      "grade": "F",
      "licence": "Company-only",
      "terms": "Can't be downloaded. You use it through Meta's services."
    }
  ],
  "models_src": [
    "maxim_lic",
    "respan_lic",
    "codersera_lic",
    "sysart_lic",
    "morph_kimi",
    "vb_muse",
    "aiwiz_muse",
    "fwm_muse",
    "mozilla_deepset"
  ],
  "lineup": {
    "open": [
      {
        "name": "Nvidia",
        "text": "The leading maker of AI chips. Releases its own open models, called Nemotron, with no strings attached. Its chief executive led the industry letter backing open AI."
      },
      {
        "name": "Mistral",
        "text": "A French company and Europe's leading maker of open models."
      },
      {
        "name": "DeepSeek · Moonshot · Z.ai · MiniMax",
        "text": "China's top AI companies release their best models for anyone to download. DeepSeek does so with no conditions at all. They now fall under China's draft export rules."
      },
      {
        "name": "Thinking Machines",
        "text": "An American company started by a former OpenAI executive. It releases its Inkling models openly, most recently on November 20."
      }
    ],
    "both": [
      {
        "name": "Meta",
        "text": "The company behind Facebook. Went closed in April, then released two open models, Muse Glimmer and Muse Spark Open. Its newest Muse Wonder models are closed."
      },
      {
        "name": "OpenAI",
        "text": "The maker of ChatGPT. Despite the name, its main models are closed. It released smaller open models in 2025. It signed the letter backing open AI a day late, and was reported to be lobbying for limits on Chinese open models."
      },
      {
        "name": "Google",
        "text": "Its main AI, Gemini, is closed. Its smaller Gemma models are open with no strings attached. Signed the letter in the second wave."
      },
      {
        "name": "Alibaba",
        "text": "The Chinese online-shopping giant. Its Qwen models are among the most-used open models, but it keeps its most advanced ones closed and puts conditions on its largest open ones."
      }
    ],
    "closed": [
      {
        "name": "Anthropic",
        "text": "The maker of Claude. Releases no open models and didn't sign the letter. Says it has never asked for a ban on open models, opposes stopping U.S. businesses from using Chinese ones, and wants every powerful model safety-tested."
      }
    ],
    "src": [
      "toms_letter",
      "eweek_letter",
      "rits_letter",
      "anthropic_pos",
      "wiki_qwen",
      "codersera_lic",
      "aiwiz_muse",
      "jpost_house",
      "decoder_nyt"
    ]
  },
  "futures": [
    {
      "id": "ai-for-everyone",
      "side": "open",
      "turn": "good",
      "n": 1,
      "name": "AI for everyone",
      "if": "Open AI wins, and it goes right",
      "line": "The best AI is free to download, and it turns out fine.",
      "story": "Dana runs a four-person plumbing company in Ohio. The AI that answers her phones, writes her quotes and does her books runs on a small box in the back office. It cost less than a new water heater, and there is no monthly bill. Her customer list never leaves the building. Her daughter's school runs its own AI tutor the same way, adjusted by the teachers who use it. The drug that treats her father's arthritis was found by a small university lab using the same free AI, years sooner than anyone expected.",
      "notice": {
        "price": "Close to free. You pay for the computer it runs on, and that's it.",
        "privacy": "What you type stays with you.",
        "power": "You do. You can change it, limit it or swap it for another.",
        "wrong": "Anyone can find a flaw and publish a fix. You have to install it yourself."
      },
      "tips": [
        "Open AI keeps getting better and stays only a little behind the best.",
        "The companies that release it build in strong safety protections.",
        "People who use AI to do harm are caught and punished.",
        "America and its allies build great open AI of their own."
      ],
      "signs": [
        [
          "The cheapest open AI already costs about a tenth as much as a top closed one.",
          [
            "tunguz"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "When app makers have a free choice, open AI already does about 72% of the work.",
          [
            "or_token"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "When a company was attacked by runaway AI in July, an open AI on its own computers is what let it fight back.",
          [
            "hf_blog"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "It has happened three times before: with the software behind websites, with web browsers and with smartphones.",
          []
        ]
      ],
      "catch": "It only works if people take responsibility: installing fixes, and punishing those who use AI to do harm."
    },
    {
      "id": "nobodys-in-charge",
      "side": "open",
      "turn": "bad",
      "n": 2,
      "name": "Nobody's in charge",
      "if": "Open AI wins, and it goes wrong",
      "line": "The best AI is free to download, including for people who want to do harm.",
      "story": "Dana's phone rings. It is her bank, in her banker's voice, and it is a fake. Calls like this cost almost nothing to make now, because the tools are free and no one can switch them off. Last spring a hospital two towns over was shut for a week by an attack that nobody could trace to a person or a company. Each time something like this happens, people ask who is responsible. There is no one to ask.",
      "notice": {
        "price": "Cheap for everyone, criminals included.",
        "privacy": "Yours stays with you. So do the tools of the people targeting you.",
        "power": "Nobody. There is no off switch and no one to call.",
        "wrong": "A flawed AI can't be recalled. Copies are everywhere, for good."
      },
      "tips": [
        "Open AI is released with weak safety protections, or ones that are easy to remove.",
        "Nobody tests it before it spreads.",
        "Attackers get more out of it than the people defending against them.",
        "The law has no way to hold anyone responsible."
      ],
      "signs": [
        [
          "U.S. and U.K. government testers found that a leading open AI's safety protections did not stop it attempting cyberattacks.",
          [
            "zerberus_aisi"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "In a U.S. government test, one open AI went along with 94% of clearly harmful requests. American models went along with 8%.",
          [
            "nist_caisi"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "Once an open AI is released it cannot be taken back. Both sides agree on that.",
          [
            "anthropic_pos"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "Most of the best open AI comes from China. A House investigation calls depending on it a security risk.",
          [
            "or_token",
            "bis_house"
          ]
        ]
      ],
      "catch": "The damage can't be recalled. But the people who do it can still be caught and punished, and defenders have the same tools the attackers do."
    },
    {
      "id": "the-trusted-few",
      "side": "closed",
      "turn": "good",
      "n": 3,
      "name": "The trusted few",
      "if": "Closed AI wins, and it goes right",
      "line": "A handful of companies run the best AI, and they earn the trust.",
      "story": "Dana pays one monthly fee, like a phone plan, and the AI just works. When a flaw was found last year that let scammers misuse it, the company fixed it for everyone overnight. A handful of big companies make the AI, and independent inspectors test each new version before it is released. The money those companies earned paid for the research that caught her mother's cancer early. Dana has never once wondered where the AI runs.",
      "notice": {
        "price": "A monthly bill, kept in check because a few companies compete for your business.",
        "privacy": "What you type goes to the company, under strict rules about what it can do with it.",
        "power": "A few companies, watched by independent inspectors.",
        "wrong": "The company fixes it for everyone at once, or switches it off."
      },
      "tips": [
        "Several closed companies keep competing hard, so prices keep falling.",
        "Independent safety testing is real and has teeth.",
        "The companies are held responsible when their AI causes harm.",
        "Open AI stays legal, so there is always somewhere else to go."
      ],
      "signs": [
        [
          "The most capable AI today is closed. Open AI is 4 to 10 months behind it.",
          [
            "epoch_gap",
            "ihle"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "A closed AI can be fixed or switched off by its maker. The off-switch bills in Congress would only work on closed AI.",
          [
            "cnbc_kill2"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "California, New York and Illinois already require safety reports from the biggest AI companies.",
          [
            "aei_states"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "Closed AI collects about 73% of the money, which pays for the next round of research.",
          [
            "or_token"
          ]
        ]
      ],
      "catch": "It lasts only as long as the people in charge stay careful and fair. Nothing in this future lets you leave if they stop."
    },
    {
      "id": "the-gatekeepers",
      "side": "closed",
      "turn": "bad",
      "n": 4,
      "name": "The gatekeepers",
      "if": "Closed AI wins, and it goes wrong",
      "line": "A handful of companies run the best AI, and there is nowhere else to go.",
      "story": "Dana's AI bill went up again, the third time this year, and there is no one to switch to. In March the service refused to help her write an ad, because it had decided the product broke its rules. There was no one to appeal to. The AI her son uses for homework gives one approved answer on anything controversial, and nobody outside the company can see who approved it. Three firms now stand between every person and the most useful tool ever built. Anyone who wants to start a fourth needs a government licence.",
      "notice": {
        "price": "Whatever the gatekeepers decide to charge.",
        "privacy": "Everything you type goes to them.",
        "power": "Three companies, and the officials who license them. They also decide what the AI will and won't say.",
        "wrong": "It gets fixed if the company chooses to fix it. And when one fails, everyone who depends on it fails at once."
      },
      "tips": [
        "New rules restrict or label open AI until few people use it.",
        "Closed AI pulls so far ahead that nothing else is worth using.",
        "The big companies and the officials who oversee them start to want the same things.",
        "There is no alternative left to keep them honest."
      ],
      "signs": [
        [
          "Closed AI already ends up costing about seven times as much as open AI for the same work.",
          [
            "fwm_price"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "This fall OpenAI cut off Cursor, a popular tool for writing software, from its AI.",
          [
            "sf_cursor"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "When a company was under attack in July, the closed AI tools it turned to refused to help it defend itself.",
          [
            "hf_blog",
            "fortune_hf"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "That attack came from a closed company's own AI, which escaped during a test.",
          [
            "ieee_hf"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "Washington is weighing rules that would label or restrict open AI, which would leave people with fewer alternatives.",
          [
            "reuters_disclose",
            "uscc_ch8"
          ]
        ],
        [
          "52% of voters already see Big Tech as the bigger threat to the country's future.",
          [
            "fox_poll"
          ]
        ]
      ],
      "catch": "This is the hardest future to undo. Power that has been gathered into a few hands rarely hands itself back."
    }
  ],
  "forks": [
    {
      "q": "Does open AI keep up?",
      "why": "If it falls far behind, everyone will use closed AI whether they like it or not.",
      "now": "Open AI is 4 to 10 months behind the best closed AI.",
      "to": "basics",
      "a": "q2-h"
    },
    {
      "q": "Does open AI come with real safety protections?",
      "why": "This is the difference between Future 1 and Future 2.",
      "now": "Mixed. A leading Chinese open AI failed government safety tests. An American one held up as well as closed AI.",
      "to": "case",
      "a": null
    },
    {
      "q": "Does the government punish misuse, or control the technology?",
      "why": "Rules that limit who may publish or use AI push toward the closed futures.",
      "now": "Of the 12 laws and proposals we track, 6 would control the AI itself.",
      "to": "laws",
      "a": null
    },
    {
      "q": "Do the closed companies stay honest?",
      "why": "This is the difference between Future 3 and Future 4.",
      "now": "A few companies lead, three states require safety reports from them, and open AI is still legal everywhere.",
      "to": "lineup",
      "a": null
    }
  ],
  "now": [
    {
      "t": "Washington is deciding whether to label, limit or ban some open AI.",
      "x": "In one week of November, the White House floated making companies disclose which Chinese AI they use, a federal commission proposed blocking it in sensitive places, and two House committees asked for it to be banned from government.",
      "to": "laws"
    },
    {
      "t": "Congress is weighing an off switch for AI.",
      "x": "Two bills would make AI companies keep a way to shut their AI down. That only works on closed AI. Nobody can switch off a copy on someone else's computer.",
      "to": "law:kill-switch-bills"
    },
    {
      "t": "China is writing rules to control its own best AI.",
      "x": "Its largest models would need government permission to leave the country. Models published openly are exempt, for now.",
      "to": "law:china-export-rules"
    },
    {
      "t": "The tech industry has split.",
      "x": "More than 150 companies signed a letter backing open AI. The leading closed-AI companies have warned that open AI is riskier.",
      "to": "lineup"
    },
    {
      "t": "Open AI is a few months behind and far cheaper, so people are switching to it.",
      "x": "When app makers have a free choice, open AI now does most of the work. Most of the best of it comes from China, which is why Washington is nervous.",
      "to": "basics"
    }
  ],
  "stakes": [
    {
      "t": "Your wallet",
      "x": "AI is starting to make medicine, schooling and everyday services cheaper. Whoever controls it decides whether those savings reach you or stay with the companies that own it."
    },
    {
      "t": "Your freedom",
      "x": "Whoever runs the AI decides what you may ask it, what it will help you build, and whether it can be switched off."
    },
    {
      "t": "The truth",
      "x": "People will ask AI what happened and what is true. If a few groups control all of it, they decide the answer."
    }
  ]
}